This week’s #SEOForLunch sponsors are Profound and Jolly Search.
SEO and organic marketing have finally hit their awkward teenage years. Not a girl, not yet a woman. (Any Britney fans!?)
This has created a problem for the people holding the marketing budget. If SEO is dead, do we move the money somewhere else? If organic search is generating 60% of last year’s clicks and revenue, should we cut its budget by 40%?
Leadership has to answer these questions while the channel changes beneath them. Nobody has perfect information, but budgets still need to be allocated and decisions still need to be made.
Apparently, waffling has become a CMO’s favorite pastime.
Pass the syrup. Let’s break this down further.
AI transparency note: AI helped outline this issue, edited my draft, generated the hero image, and genuinely made my writing more structured. The perspective and client experience are mine; I approved the final version, snark and all.
Thank you to Profound for sponsoring this week’s #SEOForLunch
Who’s winning Black Friday in AI search?
AI is changing which brands get recommended for Black Friday. Profound analyzed nearly 280,000 AI responses across four markets to see who’s winning, and which seasonal pages and publisher guides are driving those recommendations. The research also covers what marketers can update now to make their offers easier for AI to find and feature.
Same small budget. More mouths to feed.
Across my clients and conversations with marketing leaders, I’m not seeing companies cut SEO spend completely. Many are holding budgets flat while asking that money to produce significantly more.
When clicks and revenue are down, keeping your budget can feel like a win. Until you realize you’re expected to maintain traditional SEO, optimize for all things AI, and forecast the exact ROI of each effort to justify your existence. All while layoffs in other departments reduce the support needed to deliver all those results.
Gartner’s 2025 CMO Spend Survey put SEO at roughly 9% of digital channel budgets. In my experience, traditional SEO is already underfunded. My clients certainly aren’t allocating anything close to that share of their digital budgets to organic search. That money already has plenty of work to do before anyone adds AI, Reddit, chunking, or another .md file to the assignment. (Sigh.)
The problem starts when leadership expects the original results PLUS new AI visibility wins from the same investment. And of course, those AI efforts are expected to deliver returns comparable to paid search. We’re talking about brand visibility in one meeting and asking why it hasn’t hit a paid search ROAS target in the next. (double sigh…)
If you expect paid search returns, you need to explain how the work you’re funding will produce them. You can rename part of your SEO budget GEO. That doesn’t give your team more resources or turn an AI mention into a sale.
You keep restarting the experiment.
So what happens when AI visibility work doesn’t deliver the paid search returns leadership expected? Apparently, CMO law requires an immediate pivot.
The strategy you approved last month gets rewritten.
Double down on AI.
Schema everything.
Generate all the page copy automagically.
Meanwhile, good luck getting engineering time for those critical technical fixes you’ve been requesting since before ChatGPT entered the chat.
Yet leadership keeps asking, “What’s going on with SEO?!”
To give leadership some credit, some of these ideas are worth testing (even if they told you NO when you first suggested them). But every new priority takes resources away from something else. Content gets paused. Technical fixes get pushed back. The team spends another week revising the roadmap and securing buy-in for a plan that was already approved.
Your budget keeps burning even when the work stops shipping.
The work changes. The expectations and reporting deadlines don’t.
Then SEO gets blamed for the decision making.
Monthly reports start showing money spent and KPIs being missed. What it doesn’t show is how often priorities changed, implementation stalled, or resources disappeared. The takeaway becomes “SEO doesn’t work,” and another budget cut follows.
But search professionals don’t get a free pass. If we agreed to unrealistic goals, chased shiny tactics, or failed to explain what each pivot would delay, we helped create this mess. Getting the work shipped is part of our responsibility, too.
Leadership owns the priorities and resources it approves. We own the recommendations, expectations, and tradeoffs we communicate.
A strategy that never got implemented hasn’t been fairly tested. But blaming leadership won’t save our credibility either. Until both sides own their decisions, budgets and jobs remain at risk while “SEO is dead” gets another endorsement.
Pick a priority. Give it a fair shot.
Leadership and search teams need to agree on the business outcome, what the budget can realistically support, and when everyone needs to evaluate progress. Decide up front what evidence would justify a change in direction. If the goal is AI brand visibility, stop grading it against a paid search ROAS target.
If the budget can only support one priority properly, choosing that priority is your job. Search professionals need to explain the tradeoffs. Leadership needs to own the decision.
Course corrections are part of the job. But another alarming LinkedIn post isn’t proof your strategy failed, especially when half of it hasn’t shipped.
Make the call, fund the work, and give your team a fair chance to deliver.
Waffles are for breakfast. Stop serving them at budget meetings.
~Nick
Thank you to Jolly for sponsoring this week’s #SEOForLunch

Can AI Even Read Your Website?
Brought to you by Jolly Search.
Quick test: open your homepage, view the page source, and search for a sentence you can see on the page. If it isn't in the source, ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity can't see it either.
We've audited sites that look perfect in Chrome and completely blank to AI crawlers. The owners had no idea. The Sitewide AI Visibility Audit tells you:
Whether AI can read you: 9 technical factors, graded A to F.
What to fix first: findings ranked by impact, with a plan your developer can run with.
Where AI is looking instead: your presence across the channels AI engines actually cite.
$250. Five business days. Credited if you start any Jolly plan within 30 days.


